Marshmallow bliss!

marshmallow collage.resize

With Easter right around the corner, I’ve been spending a lot of time thinking of how I’m going to turn this usually extra sugary holiday into a real (fun) food occasion.  I can tell my kids are getting anxious about how our “Junk Free Journey” is going to be impacting their day of hopping down the trail of jellybean joy.  Every time we enter  the supermarket we walk smack dab into Easter candy land and as I push the cart past as fast as I can the kids start calling out to the invisible Easter Bunny, “please bring me those chocolates! Easter Bunny please bring me those yellow things!” and whatever else they can catch a glimpse of as we go speeding past.

It recently occurred to me that “those yellow things” ( the Peeps) are really just marshmallows, so I started my own Easter hunt to track down a recipe to make these with real food.  I am so happy I did because I found the most delicious, easy, recipe on that is not only junk free, but is also a million times tastier than the packaged version.  

And speaking of the packaged version, have you ever taken a minute to look at the ingredients label?  yuck!  They are little squares of sugar, corn syrup (another word for sugar), dextrose (more sugar), a chemical I can’t pronounce and that I definitely don’t have in my pantry, and food coloring.  Since when did we start thinking of these things as special treats for our children?!


Why buy this when you can make your own in 15 minutes? And if you have a stand mixer, they basically make themselves! You do need to let them set for 8 hours, which is a major challenge in my house. At the end of 8 hours our pan of marshmallows had several tunnels in it made by impatient little fingers, but they were still delicious and got a thumbs up from everyone in the house (which never happens). I also discovered they’re delicious on top of my coffee instead of the usual honey and milk I usually put in. Who says you can’t have a “treat” in the morning if it’s made with real food?


Marshmallow bliss!
Recipe Type: dessert
  • 1 cup water
  • 4 Tablespoons gelatin
  • 1 cup honey
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla
  1. Boil 1 cup of water and pour 1/2 of it into the bowl of a stand mixture.
  2. Add the gelatin and whisk to combine then set aside.
  3. To the remaining hot water add 1 cup of honey and heat over medium heat to 230 degrees F. Use a candy thermometer for this and don’t stir it, just let it slowly come to the right temperature.
  4. When the honey mixture is ready, turn your stand mixture on medium speed and pour the honey into the mixing bowl to combine with the gelatin. When the honey is all in, turn the speed up to high and let it mix for 5 – 10 minutes until it turns white with soft peaks.
  5. Add the vanilla in for the last minute or two.
  6. When the marshmallow fluff is ready spread it out in a 9×13 pan that’s lined with parchment paper.
  7. Set the pan aside somewhere dry (and out of the reach of little fingers!) for about 8 hours. Don’t put it in the ‘fridge or it will get sticky.
  8. Once fully set, turn the pan out onto a cutting board lightly greased with coconut oil (or butter) and cut into squares with a greased knife or pizza cutter.
  9. I smeared coconut oil on little duck and bunny cookie cutters and cut out marsmallow shapes.
  10. enjoy!



This entry was posted in dessert, Uncategorized.

4 thoughts on “Marshmallow bliss!

  1. Is there a non-animal based gelatin available? If so, do you know where I can purchase it? It’s almost impossible to find marshmallows that aren’t made with animal gelatin. If you were able to find some, I’d love to try this recipe!

    1. Hi Beth, There’s a seaweed product called Agar that should work, although I haven’t tried it. You might be able to find the powdered version at Asian grocery stores and health food stores. It comes in flakes and in a powdered version and the powder would allow you to substitute 1 Tablespoon Agar for 1 Tablespoon gelatin. Let me know if you try it, I’d love to hear how it turns out!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *